5 Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers (Tested) 2024

Coffee makers are not only the best in coffee brewing but also easier to clean and maintain and that’s why many coffee lovers are moving towards getting a coffee maker.

However, it’s hard to find the one coffee maker which will single-handedly provide you everything required. Therefore, we have brought before you the top 5 best 5 cup coffee makers so you can get the best coffee maker for yourself and your family. 

In this article we have featured the best of all coffee makers with the capacity of 5 cups, perfect for a bachelor or a couple.

Moreover, we have also provided detailed reviews of those coffee makers so you can know how they actually work. Besides that, we have also provided a short yet beneficial buying guide. Now, let’s get started with the reviews of the best 5 cup coffee brewers. 

At a Glance:

Top 5 Best 5 cup coffee makers

DesignCoffee MakerRetailer
1. Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker
Check Price
Check Price
3. Mr. Coffee 2134286
Check Price
4. BOSCARE 5 Cup Coffee Maker
Check Price
5. Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker
Check Price

1. Capresso 5-Cup Mini Drip Coffee Maker

Why do we love it?

  • This 5 cup coffee maker by Capresso is the one if you want a coffee maker to last for at least 5 years 
  • It keeps the coffee hot for at least 2 hours after brewing with its hot plate 
  • Moreover, the stainless steel and plastic build makes it durable and lightweight at the same time. 

The Capresso 5 cup coffee maker tops our list of best 5 cup coffee makers because of its strong build and great brewing skills.

You can easily operate the coffee maker as you have to simply get the required amount of coffee grounds in its reusable golden filter and start brewing. Moreover, you can also program your brew and set a timer for brewing your next coffee cup. 

Also, you can easily get a cup of coffee even though the coffee is not fully brewed with its drip stop feature. However, it’s kinda hard to clean as the reusable filter is not great.

Therefore, you can use a paper filter if you have a thought of buying this coffee maker.


  • Keeps coffee hot for a longer time 
  • Comes with a clock and timer 
  • Easy to use buttons 
  • Takes a small space 


  • Carafe lid is loose 
  • Filter is hard to clean 

This Capresso coffee maker is one of the top rated 5 cup coffee makers which can easily brew coffee with no mess. Moreover, it’s programmable which makes it perfect for busy and working people who have minimum time to waste on a mere coffee cup.

However, do make sure you keep the handle at its place while pouring as it’s loose and may spill your coffee. Besides that, it’s a pleasant option to go for if you are an individual living alone. 


Why do we love it?

  • Comes with a water window so you will never run out of water while brewing coffee 
  • Moreover, it’s one of the best coffee makers under $30 with a durable build and compact design 
  • Lastly, you can pause the brewing and get a cup of coffee if you are running late. 
See also  6 Best Coffee Makers for College 2024

Want a coffee maker under $30? This runner up of the best 5 cup coffee brewers would be the best choice for you. Depending on its price range, it’s worth the quality you get.

Moreover, there are two color options to choose from so you can get one of those. Also, the coffee maker features a single on/off switch with no confusing buttons. Therefore, you have to press only one button to brew coffee. 

Moreover, you can place it anywhere according to your preference and can be transported anywhere due to its lightweight.

However, you can’t get the automatic features such as different coffee strengths, temperature control. If you want those, you can go for other programmable coffee makers.


  • Keeps coffee warm 
  • Reusable mesh filter 
  • Single touch controls 
  • Portable and lightweight design 


  • Does Not include auto shut off 
  • Only one coffee strength 

We would recommend this coffee maker for someone with a low budget and searching for a short-term replacement because even though it has a good build, it’s not up to the mark and won’t be a long-term investment.

However, when it comes to coffee brewing, it extracts the right flavors and brews coffee on time. Hence, you can consider this option while getting a 5 cup small coffee maker for yourself. 

3. Mr. Coffee 2134286

Why do we love it?

  • It has a small and portable design unlike other big coffee makers which cannot accommodate in larger spaces 
  • Also, it maintains the optimal temperature required for brewing coffee and keeps coffee warm for a longer time 
  • Moreover, the build quality is good enough to last longer than many cheap coffee makers of the same price range 

Coming from a well-known brand like Mr. Coffee, we can say it’s the perfect one as it has a price range under $30 and makes decent coffee.

However, its plastic build may be a problem for some people but trust us, it’s durable enough, and the coffee doesn’t taste like plastic. Moreover, the plastic build also makes it lightweight which will work great if you like changing places from time to time. 

Besides that, this Mr. Coffee maker comes with a strong glass carafe with a cool to touch handle. Also, you can take it out anytime during brewing by pausing the brew and can get a cup of coffee.

However, we encountered that, due to the faulty spout design, the coffee may spill outside. 


  • Easy to use interface 
  • Pause brew function 
  • Compact design 
  • Water window is provided


  • No auto shut off feature 
  • Spout design is faulty 

We would say, it’s a nice one as it would stay for a longer time and has no building issues. However, the only thing that bothered us is that it’s only for right-handed people and left-handed ones can have problems while operating it.

Besides that, it keeps the coffee warm and is easy to operate. Hence, you should definitely buy this coffee maker if you want the best semi-automatic coffee maker under $30. 

4. BOSCARE 5 Cup Coffee Maker

Why do we love it?

  • It’s one of the fast brewing coffee maker which takes only 5 minutes to brew 5 cups of coffee 
  • Moreover, it comes with an auto shut off feature which makes sure the coffee maker doesn’t get burnt 
  • Lastly, the 5 cup capacity glass carafe provided is strong enough and lets you see the status of brewing 
See also  8 Best Dual Coffee Makers (Tested) 2024

Popular amongst the masses as one of the best 5 cup coffee makers under $40 this Boscare 5 cup coffee maker will be an eye-catcher in your house with its premium looks and incredibly precise coffee brewing quality.

Moreover, you won’t get confused while using it as it features a single button to brew coffee. Also, you get a worthy build quality but it’s not that great. 

Moreover, what makes it stand out is its brewing time, as it only takes 5-6 minutes for brewing a batch and you can make more coffee if you want.

However, do not excessively use it for a longer time as it’s not made for that. Besides that, it’s great and we would recommend this coffee maker to anyone with a lower budget. 


  • Clear and simple buttons 
  • Easy to clean 
  • Looks great 
  • Brews within 5 minutes 


  • Coffee may smell plastic 
  • Build quality is not good

If you want to give it a try, you can as it makes good quality coffee with the right flavor and aroma. However, it’s made of plastic and will require a few washes to get rid of the smell. Therefore, if you think of getting this one, you should know it.

Besides that, it’s quick and can let you have a cup of coffee even when you are late. Hence, you can go for it but there are many other options you can choose from. 

5. Mr. Coffee Advanced Brew 5 Cup Programmable Coffee Maker

Why do we love it?

  • You can set a timer to delay brew and have freshly brewed coffee whenever required 
  • Features an automatic shutoff feature so even if you forget to shut it down it will do that for you 
  • Moreover, it comes with a stainless steel carafe or a glass carafe, so you have the option to choose any of those

So now it’s the last yet one of the best 5 cup programmable coffee maker by Mr. Coffee. This one can make your life easier and will never make you late for your office or anywhere as it brews fast.

Moreover, you can pause it while brewing if you require an urgent shot of coffee while running late. Or else, you can also schedule brew the previous night and it will make coffee for you at the given time. 

Besides that, you can also clean it easily and it’s really easy to maintain with its removable parts. However, it doesn’t come with a reusable filter so you have to use paper filters or get one externally. Other than that, it’s one of the best coffee makers under $50


  • Small footprint 
  • Includes pause feature 
  • Brews quickly 
  • Delay brew feature 


  • Panel is not lighted 
  • Coffee spills while pouring

Other than coffee brewing there are many premium features which work perfectly and that’s why we call it one of the best automatic coffee makers of 2021.

The 5 cup capacity will be perfect for a couple with fewer coffee needs. Besides that, the carafe is not well designed and makes a mess while pouring so keep a damp cloth handly. Otherwise, it’s a good coffee maker according to its price range.

Buying Guide for Coffee Makers 

Getting the right coffee maker is essential as you invest your money into it and time for searching for a good one. Therefore, Here is a small yet useful buying guide for coffee makers so you can get the best one according to your preferences and would never regret your choice. 

See also  7 Best Automatic Pour Over Coffee Makers in 2024

Capacity of the coffee maker 

Coffee makers are available in different capacities ranging from small 4 cups to big 14 cups. Therefore, do check the capacity before getting one.

If you are a bachelor, a small 4-5 cup coffee maker would be best for you. However, if you have a large coffee loving family a 12 to 14 cups coffee maker will be best suited for you. 


You don’t have to get an expensive coffee maker for enjoying a premium coffee cup because they are available in a varied price range, ranging from mere $15 up to $300. Therefore, you can get anything in between.

Moreover, we have also provided a list of best coffee makers according to different price ranges so do check them once. 

Build quality of the coffee maker 

Most of the time, it does happen that the build quality of the coffee maker depends on its price but it’s not true all the time as you can get expensive ones with bad construction.

However, choose one with a durable and long-lasting build. Moreover, if you are going for a glass carafe, it’s better to get a thick and strong one. 

Additional features 

If you have a simple coffee maker with a single button, you won’t get any additional features. However, if you want a semi-automatic or super-automatic coffee maker, you can get features such as the delay brew function which lets you set a timer for brewing coffee and different coffee strengths and temperatures. Therefore, look for one according to your preferences. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the healthiest coffee makers?

The healthiest coffee makers are those who have BPA free material build or a metal build. All of the 5 coffee makers in this list are made from BPA free so they are safe to use.

How long can I use a coffee maker?

It depends totally on you. However, we would say, you should get a new coffee maker every 5 years for a consistent coffee quality. Because it may seem good from the outer side, but there is much going on inside. 

What is the best inexpensive coffee maker?

We would recommend you to get the BLACK+DECKER 5-Cup Coffee Maker if you are searching for an inexpensive coffee maker with a price range under $30. This coffee maker is worth trying and can brew amazing coffee shots. 

For how much time can I delay coffee brewing?

The delay time depends on the model of your coffee maker so check its user manual. However, programmable coffee makers usually can delay a brew for less than 24 hours. 


So now that you have your confusion cleared and chosen the best 5 cup coffee maker for yourself, we would like it if you appreciate our efforts and buy one of those coffee makers.

We have tried our best and also had a word with experts while short-listing these 5 best coffee makers so you can have an easy time choosing.

Now we are taking your leave and will be back with more such informative articles for you. 

Share post on

SipCoffeePro is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.